Monday, March 9, 2009

On Definition A and Definition B

The term “success” has been thrown about dozens of times in class discussions this past week and yet, “success” is a highly relative term. If I may use a rhetorical example I observed in countless of last year’s Senior Speeches: according to Merriam Webster dictionary, the term “success” can mean either “a favorable or desired outcome” or “the attainment of wealth, favor, or eminence.” Upon first glance, it seems obvious that neither of these definitions can be seen within the Loman family. And yet, on closer inspection, perhaps “success” *can* be found.

By the end of the play, Biff has come to a stunning realization, a final disillusionment. He finally frees himself from the mesh of lies that have supported his father and his household. In a way, this could certainly be seen as “a favorable or desired outcome.” So, perhaps, in his own way, Biff *has,* if inadvertently, stumbled upon success. Sure, he may not look upon this disillusionment as true success, but it is without a doubt one of the single greatest moments of his young life. For, now that he has stumbled upon this hidden success, Biff is now free to work toward true happiness, the ultimate “favorable or desired outcome.”

What is odd, though, is how limiting the second definition of “success” actually is. Can not one achieve success without “the attainment of wealth, favor, or eminence?” For some, of course, the answer is “no.” In my personal opinion, the definition of “success” is unique for each individual person. Now, I am usually not one to go against the dictionary, however, in this instance, I believe it to be necessary. Was becoming a prominent salesman truly the key to “success” in Willy’s life? Probably not. I can just as easily see the man killing himself as a “successful” CEO. His life would still be empty. His life would still be devoid of that which would have given him the true “favorable or desired outcome:” happiness for himself and his two sons. Would it be possible for Willy *ever* to achieve full “success?” Again, probably not. He is too set in his ways and his dreams. However, his boys still have that opportunity, and Biff seems well on his way.

373

Monday, February 23, 2009

On Act III and Seriously?

Alright, was I the only one surprised with Act III of A Doll’s House? I mean, seriously. Where the hell did that ending come from? Dr. Rank dies, Krogstad shows a complete change of heart and runs off with Mrs. Linde, Nora runs off without any thought of her children (but that’s an entirely different blog entry), and everything about Nora’s forgery is revealed to Torvald but this exposure seems to no longer be that big of a deal! I’m sorry but Act III seems so out of place with the entire rest of the play! Acts I and II seemed to be leading………somewhere! And instead, the audience is faced with a shot from left field! For such an example of “realism,” the ending hardly seems realistic in the slightest. How will Nora meet the demands of life on her own? Has Torvald seen *any* emotional growth? Nothing has come to any satisfying conclusion! (Except, perhaps, Dr. Rank, but was it seriously necessary to kill him off?) I guess my main issue is with Krogstad and his immediate reversal of attitude. He was used until he was no longer useful to the plot and then cast aside. What depth is there in that? Acts I and II gave me so much hope. I was looking forward to an amazingly sweet ending! And then was faced with…….this. ……..…..Gosh, it’s like Episode I.

231 words.

On Rehearsal and My Blog

Alright, due to several costume issues, I had to stay rather late at rehearsal tonight. I am merely posting to say I have just gotten home and am writing my blog now. It shall be up soon.

Good things come to those who wait.

-MJPT

Friday, February 13, 2009

On Hamlet and The Simpsons

Sadly, I could not manage to actually post the video directly do my blog like I did with The Who, but here's the link. The Simpsons do Hamlet. Enjoy.

http://www.milkandcookies.com/link/54549/detail/

-MJPT

P.S. AP English students should also enjoy the Oedipus allusion in the first few seconds.

Thursday, February 12, 2009

On Rosencrantz and Guildenstern

The friendly, philosophical, interchangeable, Rosencrantz and Guildenstern, Hamlet’s life-long friends, are condemned to death by the very man they thought they could trust. What the Hell, Robert? What the Hell? (Please excuse the Hemingway allusion. It’s for you, Schooner.) Does friendship mean nothing to Hamlet? Or is he merely so concentrated on revenge that he focuses on nothing else? (A la Edmond Dantes of Alexandre Dumas’s The Count of Monte Cristo) In the course of the play, it is established that Guildenstern and Rosencrantz are good friends of the Danish prince. And yet, Hamlet willingly and unflinchingly writes his friends off to death without a second glance. Seriously, Hamlet? It has been argued by many that Rosenstern and Guildencrantz deserved their terrible fate. After all, they sided with the corrupt king to become spies against their friend. They are a symbol of the corrupting power of the court. But really, can we blame them? It’s not like they were doing anything….evil. Or really that terrible at all! They were merely following the orders of the king so that they might uncover the truth behind Hamlet’s madness and, by doing so, help cure their childhood friend. Hamlet suspects the two have “sided” with Claudius from the beginning and, upon realizing his suspicions are true, decides first to write them from his life and then, suddenly, end their lives with a letter! (Hamlet, like a Sith, seems to deal in absolutes.) What does this reveal about Hamlet’s character? In what mental state must a man be to have no regard for the lives of, if not friends, acquaintances? Obviously, not the correct one. We know that Hamlet’s a bit mad, however, that does not excuse him from killing R & G. One might pardon Hamlet for wishing to kill Claudius. One might also even pardon Hamlet for ending Polonius’s life, for he truly did not mean to kill Ophelia’s father. (Even though stabbing might NOT be the best way to discover what’s behind a curtain. I have discovered that simply asking for a name BEFORE stabbing can avert potentially embarrassing murders.) But one can simply not write off Hamlet’s murder of Guildencrantz and Rosenstern. No matter how awesome Hamlet might be, this murder puts a serious spot (Out, damned spot!) on his record.

The fact that the Danish prince ends the lives of two innocent people, people he once called friends, cannot be overlooked in a discussion of his character. Rosencrantz and Guildenstern become merely pawns in Hamlet’s elaborate plan of revenge. They are not with him; they are against him. They must be destroyed. In this way, Guildenstern and Rosencrantz are tragic. Their fates are out of their control. They are swept away by actions they don’t understand. And, sadly, they meet their end because of a depressed prince.

RIP Rosencrantz and Guildenstern

Monday, January 26, 2009

On Unfavourable Characters and Likeability

First and foremost, I would like to apologize to all commenters for my late posting. The blog completely escaped my mind. With my first English class on Tuesday, I don’t really tend to think of it when contemplating homework due for Monday. I apologize for any inconvenience.

Most of the discussion in class has resolved around which of the characters in Antigone is the more likable. However, looking over the top choices -- Creon, Antigone, Ismene -- it is difficult to see a clear winner. We’ve got Creon, some crazed tyrant who has led himself to believe that he *is* the state. Antigone, a woman who is solely led by her own stubborn will and, while admirable in her own way, is so narrow-minded she shuns all who might disagree with her. And Ismene, a sister who cannot stand up for her own beliefs and is tossed aside by everyone when they see she is not willing to do what it takes. Were the house to be broken into at this very moment by a well-read robber and were he to put a gun to my head and thrust a copy of Sophocles’s Antigone into my hands and were he then to force me to choose the character I liked most or surrender my life to him…..………I’d choose Ismene. He’d then set the gun down and we’d have a lovely chat comparing and contrasting the differing themes of Oedipus Rex and Antigone over tea and scones. But I digress.

The odd thing is, it has become apparent that we don’t *need* to like the characters in a story. One can enjoy a piece of literature or drama without feeling any sympathy at all for any of the characters. Sure, it definitely *helps* if the reader can identify with the protagonist or even a secondary character but it seems not to be essential for a well-written work of literary genius. Another example of use of less than favourable characters is Emily Brontë ’s, Wuthering Heights. I mean, who *actually* likes Heathcliff or Catherine? But despite this, the novel is still a masterpiece of English literature.

Granted, it’s a rather odd thought. How can one commit to a piece of literature, spend so much time reading and analyzing it, and *not* dislike spending the time required to do so with such annoying characters? Yet, I can easily say in the same breath that I dislike every character found within Antigone and yet I thoroughly enjoy the play. It seems that themes trump characters. Not in every circumstance, of course. But when in the hands of an extremely skilled author or playwright, a handful of disagreeable characters can be molded into a fantastic, timeless story.

(Alright, 8 am on Monday morning isn’t bad! Plus, if there are any commenters who have forgotten, here’s an untouched blog entry!)

Monday, January 12, 2009

On Tolstoy and Condemnation

It is human nature to fear to death. As I stated both in class and in my Senior Speech, necrophobia is number one on most lists of Americans’ most popular fears. With the exception of Gerasim, basically every single character within Tolstoy’s The Death of Ivan Ilyich refuses to face his or her own mortality. Why is this? Of course, death is frightening. I fear It as well. What reason do we have not to fear it? It’s inevitable. We are unable to escape its grasp. I can easily relate to both Ivan’s and Peter’s fears.

And yet, the story seems to promote the acceptance of death and those who have the ability to look upon their own mortality without fear. Why should this fear of death be seen as a negative personality trait? I would condemn the rest of the characters far more for their narcissism, materialism, and their mesh of falsity they construct then for their simple fear of the unknown. Though, perhaps this is what Tolstoy is condemning: The fact that the characters ignore death (just as they ignore the severity of Ivan’s illness) despite the fact that it is inevitable. Instead of at least *trying* to come to terms with death (if they succeed is inconsequential), they ignore it all together. Perhaps this refusal to admit the inevitable is their flaw. Even I can admit -- most of the time, anyway -- that we will all, at some time or another, reach the end of our lives. I try not to ignore that fact.

Yet, though titled The Death of Ivan Ilyich, the novella revolves around the life he and his contemporaries led. It was not how he died, nor how he feared death, but the fact that he wasted his life purely with trivial matters that is the focus of the story. Perhaps this fear of death only comes from the realization one has not lived his or her life properly. Perhaps this is why no character can face it. Because no character can face the fact that his or her life has been lived poorly. Despite their riches and their positions, they are unable to look upon death because they cannot look upon their wasted lives.

In the end, it seems, Tolstoy’s novella about necrophobia seems not to be about the fear of death at all, but about the fear of having lived a life that was not worth the pain.

P.S. I would merely like to add that I rather enjoyed the thinning of the chapters that occurred throughout the novella as both the reader and Ivan traveled closer and closer to his death. It gave me the feeling that not only was time quickening, but also that time was running out.